1,856

of 5,000 signatures

To Dear Victoria Atkins, Wes Streeting, Daisy Cooper, Jim Shannon, Ben Lake, Dr Dasha Nichols, Amanda Pritchard and Claire Murdoch,

We are patients, survivors, carers, and campaigners, united by our painful journeys with eating disorders. We reach out to you with the raw truth of our lived experiences. Our lives, or those of our loved ones, hang in the balance, yet we find ourselves confronted with a health system that too often turns its back on us. We are writing to you because no one with an eating disorder should be dying or being told they cannot be helped. However, in 2023, we have seen a growing trend of people being denied treatment and told they are too complex, or not motivated enough to be helped. We have seen people being told they are untreatable and in some instances moving on to palliative care pathways. This is a new and worrying trend that seems to be increasingly normalised around the country, despite all good practice guidelines.

Social media is full of messages from people unable to get support: children as young as 10 stuck in general paediatric wards because there aren’t appropriate beds close to home; 20-year-olds who have been told they are not treatable as they are too complex; carers who have lost loved ones to eating disorders; and adults in their 30s, 40s, and 50s who are currently receiving palliative care or have had their treatment withdrawn based on length of illness. A 23-year-old woman's harrowing story epitomises this crisis. She was referred to the Court of Protection a year ago because her clinical teams considered her illness untreatable due to its length and severity. She is a young adult with a severe mental illness, whose death is preventable. She is now begging for treatment to survive but unable to access it. Would this be acceptable for any other mental illness?

Even though it is widely known that eating disorders are becoming more common and that they increase mortality risk, this national emergency is not being addressed. Despite their high prevalence, eating disorders are frequently stigmatised and viewed as a lifestyle choice, a phase that only affects white, underweight teenage girls who ultimately grow out of their illness. This myth may underlie the severe underfunding of adult eating disorder services. In fact, people of all ages, sizes, genders, and ethnicities are affected by eating disorders. This has been well documented in recent surveys by NHS Digital.

The guidance that was published on palliative care pathways by NHSE East of England for adults as young as 25 years old is alarming. It is insufficient to say that this document was retracted because we have evidence from the ground that these practices are spreading. The way the terminology is being used is highly concerning. Treatment withdrawal, whether referred to as a "treatment break" or "palliative care," results in the same outcome. One simply sounds less repulsive than the other.

People with eating disorders are not untreatable. However, the new NHSE guidance for adult eating disorders, which is currently being consulted on, mentions treatment withdrawal as a possible outcome when someone does not respond to the treatment that has been provided for them. This is discriminatory, and it would not be acceptable for any other health problems.

We appreciate that there is a lack of funding and issues in the workforce, but the NHS should be holding hope for people. People have the right to the best possible chance of recovery, which necessitates properly funded services.

This growing epidemic can only be reversed by investing in prevention, early intervention, timely, high-quality treatment without discrimination, and investment into research to find new and more effective treatments. But these cannot be at the expense of people who are already ill. Eating disorders can be life-threatening, but deaths are preventable regardless of the length or severity of the illness.

The PHSO raised the alarm in 2017 and repeated the call for urgent improvements to adult eating disorder services to help prevent avoidable deaths. There has been very little progress since. The NHS blames the government for a lack of funding, and the government blames the NHS for a lack of implementation.

Inpatient admissions have been steadily increasing across the age range, and due to a lack of capacity in the system, patients are often admitted to acute hospitals in a life-threatening situation. In the last year, there were 28000 hospital admissions across the age range. Current inpatient treatment results in poor outcomes and 40–50 percent relapse rates, and practices are outdated, lacking the integration of medical and psychological treatment. The safety and quality of treatment for this group need urgent attention.

Open letter text

We urge you to:

1. Cease the production of palliative care pathways for those with all types of eating disorders, and make a clear statement that palliative care is only appropriate if the person has a separate life-limiting illness and not for an eating disorder alone. Deaths from eating disorders are preventable.

2. Set up a national confidential inquiry into eating disorder deaths similar to the national confidential inquiry into suicide and homicide, which has been successful in facilitating learning from these tragedies and improving practice.

3. Bring together experts by experience and clinicians to develop the best treatments for those struggling with eating disorders,

4. Ring fence funding for eating disorder research and treatment, which has hitherto been neglected. These include funding to implement existing good practice guidelines, such as NICE and MEED, and accountability by ICBs.

9 Jan 2024
We have hit over 1000 signers!
Completely overwhelmed with the response in the last 48 hours! A huge thank you to everyone who has signed and shared this! Behind all these signatures is a unique story, a life, people who have lost family or friends or loved ones, people who are desperate for help, people who have been given up on, told they are not treatable and clinicians who know that the treatment is just not there. And it is these stories that mean we have to keep fighting for change! Please keep sharing the link!

Sign the open letter

Signers list

Hayley Jones
Poppy Burge
Josephine Long
Andrew Kuchanny
Heather Millar
Maya Chauhan
Ali Newman
Lotte Hendriksen
Claire Mclennan
Holly Ann
Joseph Barr
Emily Martin
Vivienne Lees
Avril Davison
Sheila Butler
Edwin Sheaf
Mollie Virgo
James Withey
Louise Sheridan-Brown
Suzanne Schneider
Vanessa Plumley
Pippa Johnson
John Curtis
Agnes Adams
Mark Jenner
Bethan Allen
Isabelle Baker
Jenny Muckle
Patricia Hughes
Simon
Andrew Vernon
Rachael Newham
Michael Cockett
Charlotte Morrison
Amy Mccann
Kara Murphy
Vanessa Hamilton
Helen Hall
Eileen Grout
Amanda Mccaffrey
Ian Jackson
Raza Qazi
Sarah Dummackin
Kevin Mcglinchey
Jane Anderson
Ellin Jones
Jazz Harrison
Julie Edwards
Kama Ashton
Amy Naftis

People with eating disorders are not untreatable

Next step - spread the word

You're signing this as

Not you? Click here

People with eating disorders are not untreatable

Will you chip in?

I'm chipping in £0

Secure lock symbol

Your donation is

One off Monthly

Choose your contribution amount

£200

Thanks, we just need a few more details to set up your direct debit.

Change your contribution amount

First name
Last name
Your email
Address (line 1)
Town
Your postcode
Account name
Account number
Sort code
Thank you for your donation. Please hold on while we process your details securely.